
When I was 12 years old, my favorite grandfather passed away.
As I sat beside my youth leader, I asked, "Why did he have to die?" She replied, "God was ready for him to be in heaven." That was a good answer and it made sense. At least it was as good as any answer that an adult could have given me. I was scared that God might want me in heaven sometime soon.
I was in elementary school when my aunt and uncle decided to get a divorce. As I sat beside my aunt, I asked, "Why did Uncle Dennis leave?" She said, "He doesn't love me anymore." I wondered if he had stopped loving me, too.
I was in middle school when I first understood about child abuse. My mom was on jury duty and the person on trial was being accused of abusing their child. As I sat beside my mother, I asked, "Why did that mom hit her child?" She replied, "She is full of anger and cannot control herself." I was glad she wasn't my mother.
I was in college when I heard about a girl being raped. I was naive, but I figured out what it meant. As I sat beside my sister, I asked, "Why would a man do that to a woman?" She replied, "They think they need to control other people and women are easy targets." I understood that I was a target, too.
I'm a 38 year old teacher now. About a month ago, one of my students lost his dearest uncle--his hero. As I have tried to minister to him over the last few weeks, I realize that I don't have very many answers. And the ones that I provide are weak at best. He looks at me with those doubtful eyes and I know he realizes that I absolutely have no clue as to what the right answers really are. But, he accepts them and finds some degree of comfort. My question is:
Is it wrong for me to feel terribly angry about having to answer these questions to begin with? Not angry at the student, but at the situation.
Why would a seemingly healthy 26 year old farmer die in his sleep? And, I believe my student considers whether he might die when he's 26 years old.
I am what they call in the eduation field an "existentialist." I fight to know the answer to all of life's burning questions. I have shared some of the burning questions of my life. To this day, I still have all of the questions that significant people in my life attempted to answer. But, the question mark lurks in the corner of my mind. So, I'm not so settled on these issues, I suppose.
What do you think? Is it wrong to question to God? Is it a big, fat sin for me to question death, abuse, rape, and divorce? I know....another question from an inquiring mind.